Jump to content

The Official Irish 'Might Have Beens' Thread

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

In the early 1980s, when the short-lived De Lorean car plant near Dunmurry was in operation, there was a proposal to build a siding into it and take the cars to Belfast Port via another siding off the Larne line. This would have ended up being somewhere near the Fortwilliam roundabout, very probably. The acquisition of half a dozen ex-CIE "C" class locomotives was partly with this possibility in mind.

 

Imagine that on a Belfast 1980s based layout....

 

latest?cb=20131025203348

 

Sorry, couldn't resist...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In the early 1980s, when the short-lived De Lorean car plant near Dunmurry was in operation, there was a proposal to build a siding into it and take the cars to Belfast Port via another siding off the Larne line. This would have ended up being somewhere near the Fortwilliam roundabout, very probably. The acquisition of half a dozen ex-CIE "C" class locomotives was partly with this possibility in mind.

 

Imagine that on a Belfast 1980s based layout....

 

If only there was some way that we could go back in time.......

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If NIR had been more pro-freight, there could have at one time been the possibility of -

 

- De Lorean Dunmurry to Belfast.

- Fertiliser, Guinness and cement Dundalk - Derry

- same, Dundalk - Adelaide

- Containers, North Wall - Portadown - Adelaide - Derry

 

One can but dream. NIR would need its half dozen C's, maybe more than three 071s, and probably nowadays a few scond hand 141s.....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The 6 C class GMs were bought by NIR for the proposed lignite traffic from near Ballymoney to the power stations at Kilroot and possibly Ballylumford. This also involved serious plans to reopen the"back line" from Monkstown to Greenisland, which by way has never officially been formally abandoned as a railway to my best knowledge!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There were about 6 miles of dual gauge track in Derry with mixed gauge trains as well. Dual gauge track in Larne and Ballymena as well.

 

The dual gauge track in Derry was the dock lines of the Londonderry Port & Harbour Commissioners and which connected the NCC and CDR on the South side of the river with the GNR(I) and L&LSR on the North side. The Craigavon Bridge, which was double decked had mixed gauge track on the lower deck, with access via a mixed gauge wagon turntable at each end. The LP&HC had two steam locomotives, which were fitted with drawgear and buffing gear for both 3ft and 5ft 3in gauge stock, so it would have been possible to see a train of mixed gauge stock, albeit with the loco in the middle. Incidently, both locos are still extant, one at Cultra, and No 3 R H Smyth at Whitehead.

 

In the early days of the L&LSR, narrow gauge passenger trains used the dock lines to reach a terminus behind the Guildhall in the city centre, until the Board of Trade stepped in and stopped the practice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Multi-gauge lines already exist (though not here). Sorry Harry

 

Could have made a good few bob from that Kev! If you look up the Irish Sea railway tunnel the gauge problem is seen as a very large one.They did not mention multi gauge tracks instead multi gauge trains.Not sure which would be cheaper but I would say the tracks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just been re-reading E M Patterson's history of the Clogher Valley Railway, where there is a section on extensions - including the fabled Ulster & Connaught. Seems both the Clogher and Cavan & Leitrim were keen to link up, with the former also interested in extending eastwards to the Bessbrook & Newry tramway, thereby providing a direct link to the coast for Arigna coal. The GN branch to Keady & the south eventually scuppered the coastal link, though they did build a tunnel to enable the 3' gauge line to cross beneath it. Still exists too!

Hence, even if the U&C extension to Galway and Clifton had not produced a trans Irish narrow gauge 'mainline' [over 230 miles long!], a C&L/CV/B&N link would have produced the scenario of the first two's engines & rail cars sharing tracks and working with each other's stock. 'Tis a basis for a 7mmNG project I've often pondered - not least because of the variety of modelling it could offer. So far, cannot decide if it would be best in 21mm gauge/7mm scale, or 32mm gauge/10mm[ish] scale. One day...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just been re-reading E M Patterson's history of the Clogher Valley Railway, where there is a section on extensions - including the fabled Ulster & Connaught. Seems both the Clogher and Cavan & Leitrim were keen to link up, with the former also interested in extending eastwards to the Bessbrook & Newry tramway, thereby providing a direct link to the coast for Arigna coal. The GN branch to Keady & the south eventually scuppered the coastal link, though they did build a tunnel to enable the 3' gauge line to cross beneath it. Still exists too!

Hence, even if the U&C extension to Galway and Clifton had not produced a trans Irish narrow gauge 'mainline' [over 230 miles long!], a C&L/CV/B&N link would have produced the scenario of the first two's engines & rail cars sharing tracks and working with each other's stock. 'Tis a basis for a 7mmNG project I've often pondered - not least because of the variety of modelling it could offer. So far, cannot decide if it would be best in 21mm gauge/7mm scale, or 32mm gauge/10mm[ish] scale. One day...

 

Why not follow Neill Ramseys example modelling the Irish Narrow Gauge on 45mm gauge 15mm scale

even runs on LGB track!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What would have happened if the Derry Road remained open - 3000 / 4000 class railcars and fewer open stations. Mullingar to Athlone probably just a short cut - Moate would have closed. West Cork - possibly a 2-car 2600 rattling up and fine to Bandon? And Harcourt St could have ended up as a DART terminus.....

 

Maybe one for the "might have been" thread!

 

Such is the imaginative root of some very impressive layouts....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To add.... Had oil traffic materialised at Bantry, like at Foynes, and this did seem possible at one stage, then two scenarios might have arisen. First, retention of the line purely for that traffic (ie goods only with all intermediate stations closed) or, Ballina style, retention of the line with the same minimal passenger service as well and even sugar beet too for a while. Passenger trains would have been AEC sets for a while, then probably the familiar sight if a 141, bogie and van, up to modern times. Without doubt it would today be a two car 2600.

Edited by jhb171achill
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 5 weeks later...

A T1 class 4-4-2t was proposed in 1915 at Dundalk for the GNR. Supposed to be a superheated(as built) version of the T class with a superheated boiler the same as that of the U class these locos would have had a tractive effort of 17708 lbs.5 were ordered in 1916 but the shortage of material due to the war delayed construction and lead to them being cancelled in 1919.

Edited by GSR 800
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder would Mallow-Waterford have survived

had the Ballinacourty project had come online

sooner.Mallow -Waterford closed in March 1967,

While the spur to Ballinacourty to service the

Quigley plant came about around 1970.

Trains could have run to Mallow via

Dungarvan, and perhaps beet trains

could have run via Dungarvan as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There was a proposal during World War 2 to regauge the County Donegal Railways line from Strabane to Derry. This was due to the heavy military traffic from Derry destined for places on the GNR like Omagh. Unfortunately the GNR line from Derry crossed the border into Neutral Eire, so this traffic had to be routed via Cookstown and Dungannon, with three changes of direction, a long way round. Due to the cost of upgrading the infrastructure to upgrade the narrow gauge route to standard gauge, the project never happened. Shame really, as the CDR and NCC stations in Derry were almost back to back, and through running would have been possible. A circular route from Belfast to Belfast via Londonderry.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder would Mallow-Waterford have survived

had the Ballinacourty project had come online

sooner.Mallow -Waterford closed in March 1967,

While the spur to Ballinacourty to service the

Quigley plant came about around 1970.

Trains could have run to Mallow via

Dungarvan, and perhaps beet trains

could have run via Dungarvan as well.

 

At one stage the GSWR & F&RHR had plans for a cut-off line between Dunkettle & Fermoy to reduce the overall journey time to Rosslare and the possibility of adding Fermoy to the Cork suburban network.

 

Pfitzer appear to have originally planned a much larger operation at Ballinacourty with quarries at both Bennettsbridge & Lombardstown on the Kerry road supplying dolomite. This would probably resulted in heavier magnesite & oil traffic between Ballinacourty & Cork which would have kept the western end of the line very at least until the 2nd oil crisis hit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There were two proposals of interest on NIR in the 1980s.... one was shipping of De Lorean cars from the Dunmurry factory to the docks, and the other was lignite (brown coal) from Crumlin (on the Antrim branch) to Belfast docks.

 

That's mainly what they got the six "C" class for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's happened before - the brand new 208 and 209 double headed on the ITG, "Yankee Explorer," railtour in 1996

 

There was a myth that a pair of 201s in a consist hauling a special was a little over zealous on acceleratiion causing damage to couplings on some coaches. 6400 hp would need to be eased in gradually on a heavy train. Fiction or True?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If a pair of 201s were at the front and back of a train wouldn't that cause "hunting " due to the engine at the back like what happened with the hunslet on the enterprise reopening

 

201s are not designed to be used that way.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If a pair of 201s were at the front and back of a train wouldn't that cause "hunting " due to the engine at the back like what happened with the hunslet on the enterprise reopening

 

Trains have operated in 'top and tail' fashion at high speeds around the world for at least 40 years, both powered at both ends or only at one end with no issues.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use