Jump to content

GNRi 20 Ton Bogie Covered Wagon/ Grain Van.

Rate this topic


Recommended Posts

Posted
50 minutes ago, popeye said:

Just built one and almost painted.

The RPSI Whitehead photo's were a big help.

It did get changes to it over it's life.

Noticed that the old pictures of it had grain doors and when renovated they were omitted.

  • Like 2
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, popeye said:

Just built one and almost painted.

The RPSI Whitehead photo's were a big help.

It did get changes to it over it's life.

I think there were several variants too. 

Edited by jhb171achill
  • Like 1
Posted
11 hours ago, Moogie-69 said:

This one is definitely a GNRi bogie wagon. 

20 Ton covered wagon.png

Very nice!

10 hours ago, Moogie-69 said:

Noticed that the old pictures of it had grain doors and when renovated they were omitted.

The RPSI description explains the conversions in detail. The surviving one has been restored to show elements of both the cask and grain versions.

https://www.steamtrainsireland.com/rpsi-collection/52/504-guinness-grain-van
 

I think I have some photos of it from my visit to Whitehead a couple of years ago. It is in the museum and is easily accessible on one side - and inside too. 

Posted
6 hours ago, Mol_PMB said:

That looks great! Any thoughts on doing the grain version? 

Should be able to do that, only need to delete a set of doors, add a ladder and grain doors. 

  • Like 2
Posted
24 minutes ago, Moogie-69 said:

Should be able to do that, only need to delete a set of doors, add a ladder and grain doors. 

Thanks! I could add one to my grain train. 

Posted
6 hours ago, Mol_PMB said:

Thanks! I could add one to my grain train. 

Would something like that do you ?

Couldn't get a good photo of the roof hatches, so they could be a bit off.

Guinness Grain 1 Wagon.png

Guinness Grain Wagon 2.png

  • Like 2
Posted
20 hours ago, Moogie-69 said:

Would something like that do you ?

Couldn't get a good photo of the roof hatches, so they could be a bit off.

Guinness Grain 1 Wagon.png

Guinness Grain Wagon 2.png

That looks great - thanks. I think it represents them in early preservation condition though, the doors on one side were added by the RPSI. 

When they were in service, both sides were like the upper image - these two photos show opposite sides (note the brake lever orientation):

1964-05-29-50417-504-in-maysfields-yard-

1965-00-00-50416-guinness-vans-504-and-2

Is that an easy fix?

Many thanks,

Paul

  • Like 1
Posted
1 minute ago, Moogie-69 said:

Yep, easy to sort out. Do the brake levers both point in the same direction ?

Yes, only one bogie was braked. Both brake levers point towards the unbraked end of the wagon.

  • Informative 1
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

That looks very good! Amazing detail in the print which has come out very well.

Being very picky (sorry)

There were small grab handles on the roof at the top of the ladders, easily added with a bit of wire. Maybe mark the hole positions with dimples?

Also above the bogies, there were oval holes/recesses in the solebar with rivets around, where the bolster was attached. Not sure if those can be incorporated in the print? Again, they could be drilled/added afterwards. 

The roof hatches look a bit ‘heavy’ (too tall) to my eyes but I appreciate there aren’t many good photos of the roof. 
 

image.thumb.jpeg.2eeb3e4d8eec7c2b350dba21da156759.jpeg

IMG_5341.thumb.png.67fc6b5fa122bc3080f5243d06771c60.png

I think the tall bit on the diagram is a rib along the middle, the actual plate of the hatch is lower. Look at the pics and end elevation on the diagram.

image.thumb.jpeg.3278962ec113e9b45e3c986250ddd05b.jpeg

I hope this is constructive. 
Enda will tell you I’m just as picky with him, because this only has to be got right once on the drawing and will then be duplicated many times…

Great work!

  • Like 3
Posted
5 hours ago, Mol_PMB said:

That looks very good! Amazing detail in the print which has come out very well.

Being very picky (sorry)

There were small grab handles on the roof at the top of the ladders, easily added with a bit of wire. Maybe mark the hole positions with dimples?

Also above the bogies, there were oval holes/recesses in the solebar with rivets around, where the bolster was attached. Not sure if those can be incorporated in the print? Again, they could be drilled/added afterwards. 

The roof hatches look a bit ‘heavy’ (too tall) to my eyes but I appreciate there aren’t many good photos of the roof. 
 

image.thumb.jpeg.2eeb3e4d8eec7c2b350dba21da156759.jpeg

IMG_5341.thumb.png.67fc6b5fa122bc3080f5243d06771c60.png

I think the tall bit on the diagram is a rib along the middle, the actual plate of the hatch is lower. Look at the pics and end elevation on the diagram.

image.thumb.jpeg.3278962ec113e9b45e3c986250ddd05b.jpeg

I hope this is constructive. 
Enda will tell you I’m just as picky with him, because this only has to be got right once on the drawing and will then be duplicated many times…

Great work!

Most of that is an easy fix, I don't mind the criticism,  with no clear photos of a roof I have to try and draw what I think I see on the drawings.  As you see I don't always get it right, that's everyone else's job that has more knowledge of these things than me.

Roof hatches - is 1 the upstand/ collar on the roof and 2 the smaller cap ? 3 is a single strap to hold the hatch on ? 

What do you think the 2'0" x 1'6" refers to, surly the hatches would have been square ? 

I'll update shortly.

Screenshot_20261122_124804_Samsung Browser.jpg

Screenshot_20261122_124944_Samsung Browser.jpg

  • Like 1
Posted

Sorry for taking ages to respond - really busy and away from home today. 
 

Yes, your diagram and numbering of the hatch parts looks right to me. 
 

I think that the 2’ x 1’6” is the size of the hole in the roof. 2’ along the length of the wagon and 1’6” across the width. 
The hatch would be maybe an inch bigger all round. They would have been rectangular. 
IMG_5366.thumb.png.4b46baa65298917b42616ed8bb389c19.png


IMG_5367.thumb.png.590238eacfcd7b08d1260efbc867e271.png


image.jpeg.580b01b92a3b14920f3c6bfd5e38449d.jpeg

The black thing here is a hatch:

image.jpeg.6501ef6a97bae1a086546b01f8b56d9d.jpeg

Hope that helps!

 

Some other grain wagons had round hatches but not these ones. 
 

 

Here’s a closeup of the solebar detail above the bogies, with the oval hole and rivet pattern. Also a hook for horse shunting on the left:

image.jpeg.fc10aa0b32d0647e51811ae576166793.jpeg
 

Thanks again!

Mol

  • Like 2
Posted
13 minutes ago, Moogie-69 said:

Brakes attached, they sort of represent what's on the real thing. 🤔

20 Ton Guinness brakes.png

Those brakes look pretty good based on the photos on the RPSI page. 
Only on that bogie, the other end without. 
 

Some rivets on the hornguides either side of the axleboxes?

image.jpeg.72455d781f1b357fd2c71150cdc9ebf4.jpeg

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use