Moogie-69 Posted October 18 Posted October 18 (edited) Would anyone be any good at identifying GNRi carriages ? All images are of the same train. Any help would be appreciated. Edited October 18 by Moogie-69 2
Galteemore Posted October 18 Posted October 18 Have you got Norman Johnston’s GNRI in Colour? That identifies a few, as does Des Coakham’s Irish Broad Gauge Carriages book. One of Mac Arnold’s ‘Golden Years’ also includes a carriage listing which is helpful. 1
Moogie-69 Posted October 18 Author Posted October 18 1 hour ago, Galteemore said: Have you got Norman Johnston’s GNRI in Colour? That identifies a few, as does Des Coakham’s Irish Broad Gauge Carriages book. One of Mac Arnold’s ‘Golden Years’ also includes a carriage listing which is helpful. Have Johnstons book ordered, just waiting on the post. I'll have a look for the other books, thanks.
Moogie-69 Posted October 23 Author Posted October 23 (edited) I have looked through all my books and I think the second carriage back from the engine is a class K3, could the last carriage be a brake third or something like a third/ goods carriage ? In EM Pattersons book it explains what the classes, K, L, J, ect, means but it doesn't say what the number behind the letter represents. Is there any Web sites or books that explains it better, listing all the classes with dimensions, or is there any carriage drawings available anywhere ? I wouldn't have thought that they would have had a 1st class carriage on a branch line so could the other two carriages be 2nd or 3rds ? Thanks, Noel. Edited October 23 by Moogie-69
jhb171achill Posted October 23 Posted October 23 At least one will be a composite, as all trains had at least some first class accommodation. Any idea when this was - pre-1955, when it was probably coming from Newcastle, or the very last year when trains ran only as far as Banbridge? It's hard to tell at that distance but I'd guess that the first is a brake 3rd with 7ft guard's compartment, the second I wouldn't be sure, but it's older, the third is a composite and the last a brake 3rd. No goods carried in carriages - they would be in goods wagons, and on this line run as a separate train. Looks like you'll need a couple of 0.6.0 SG3 or UG locos and an AEC railcar set! 1
Moogie-69 Posted October 23 Author Posted October 23 After a bit of rough measuring, if the second carriage is a K3 at 48ft that would make the following, First carriage - approximately 56ft. Third carriage - approximately 60ft. Forth carriage - approximately 55ft. So, could the first carriage be a K6 ? The forth carriage, Banbridge had a K19 which held 60 passengers and had a small luggage and brake compartment but it was only 43ft 6in whereas the one in the photo is measuring about 55ft. More research required but I'm not sure where to look next.
Mol_PMB Posted October 23 Posted October 23 There are GNR carriage experts but I’m afraid I’m not one of them. If it was GSWR I could help. @Richard EH perhaps? 1
Paul 34F Posted Sunday at 15:23 Posted Sunday at 15:23 Hello, the second carriage is definitely a K3, 3rd class coach. The last vehicle is an L class 3rd class with brake. I’m not near my computer at the moment, but maybe able to check later or tomorrow. Paul 1
Moogie-69 Posted Sunday at 16:07 Author Posted Sunday at 16:07 (edited) What i have found out is they are possibly, K3, L4, L8 and F2 but i cant remember which one is which. Waiting on some info from Richard at IRRS, so should be able to say then which is which. Edited Sunday at 16:37 by Moogie-69
jhb171achill Posted Sunday at 16:17 Posted Sunday at 16:17 The unique tricomposite, No. 19, ran on that line latterly. It had a clerestorey roof, and a gangway at one end only. At the gangway end was a toilet, then an open section (3rd class), and that was as far as the internal corridor went. From memory, there was then a (non-corridor) first class compartment, a second class compartment, and a small brake van end, with no gangway at that end. It ended its days still in brown with the UTA, and was withdrawn about 1960 (again from memory). 1 1
Paul 34F Posted Tuesday at 15:30 Posted Tuesday at 15:30 Noel, Apologies for the late reply, I have been dealing with officialdom for the last couple of days. As you have already commented about the train formation, I can concur the train consists of; L8, non corridor, 9 compartment Brake 3rd; K3, clerestory non corridor, 8 and two quarter compartment 3rd; F2, non corridor, 9 compartment 1st / 2nd composite, reclassified 1st class after abolition of 2nd class; L4 non corridor, 5 compartment Brake 3rd. This carriage can be identified as 353. It was unique in having its Guard Lookouts removed in Jan. 1944. In the GNRI Diagram book the company referred to thd Guards Lookouts as Caboose! Hope this information is of use Kind regards Paul 1
Moogie-69 Posted Wednesday at 21:36 Author Posted Wednesday at 21:36 On 17/11/2026 at 3:30 PM, Paul 34F said: Noel, Apologies for the late reply, I have been dealing with officialdom for the last couple of days. As you have already commented about the train formation, I can concur the train consists of; L8, non corridor, 9 compartment Brake 3rd; K3, clerestory non corridor, 8 and two quarter compartment 3rd; F2, non corridor, 9 compartment 1st / 2nd composite, reclassified 1st class after abolition of 2nd class; L4 non corridor, 5 compartment Brake 3rd. This carriage can be identified as 353. It was unique in having its Guard Lookouts removed in Jan. 1944. In the GNRI Diagram book the company referred to thd Guards Lookouts as Caboose! Hope this information is of use Kind regards Paul Thanks very much Paul, there is so much information out there, is just knowing where to look. Pity there wasn't an online digital library that all this great information was searchable. 1
Paul 34F Posted 17 hours ago Posted 17 hours ago Most of the information I have gathered has been from the GNRI carriages books, various different carriage lists and cross referencing images in various Irish railway books I have and trawling through images online. It would be a great thing to publish everything, but I would need copyright permission for all the images. Something for the future perhaps. Paul 1
Paul 34F Posted 14 hours ago Posted 14 hours ago On 15/11/2026 at 6:17 PM, jhb171achill said: The unique tricomposite, No. 19, ran on that line latterly. It had a clerestorey roof, and a gangway at one end only. At the gangway end was a toilet, then an open section (3rd class), and that was as far as the internal corridor went. From memory, there was then a (non-corridor) first class compartment, a second class compartment, and a small brake van end, with no gangway at that end. It ended its days still in brown with the UTA, and was withdrawn about 1960 (again from memory). This is an interesting memory of carriage 19. Has anyone seen an image of the vehicle in this condition. The carriage diagram book is a different arrangement. Paul
Colin R Posted 13 hours ago Posted 13 hours ago I have to admit to being fooled on this one. When I first saw the photo, I thought it was a bloody good model in maybe Z or N gauge; then I realised it was a photo of a real train. It is the sort of image that modellers crave to reproduce. Does it have copyright? As I would love to keep it for my modelling files. 1
Moogie-69 Posted 12 hours ago Author Posted 12 hours ago 44 minutes ago, Colin R said: I have to admit to being fooled on this one. When I first saw the photo, I thought it was a bloody good model in maybe Z or N gauge; then I realised it was a photo of a real train. It is the sort of image that modellers crave to reproduce. Does it have copyright? As I would love to keep it for my modelling files. Its from Britain from Above. just search the images around Dromore.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now