LNERW1

Just thought I'd share here a video game called NIMBY Rails. In short, it is a railway building game that allows you to build anywhere on a map of the real world, with several different types of track, ie 350km/h high speed, 160km/h medium speed, and 60km/h tram lines. I get the feeling it's suited for this forum as you have the option not only to replicate the current Irish network (or that of anywhere else in the world, for that matter), you can also rebuild closed lines that you think should still be open, or leave out those you consider pointless. I found it a while ago after stumbling across the Reddit page for the game and have since began working on my own Irish network, pictured below: The trains are colour coded based on purpose/operator, colours are listed below: Dark green- Iarnród Éireann (mainline) Light Green- Iarnród Éireann (suburban)- at the moment only DART Light Purple- Luas Dark Turquoise- NIR (mainline) Light Turquoise- NIR (suburban) Red- Trams/Metro outside Dublin My network is far from finished, but I thought it would be a good example for what can be accomplished and frankly I'd love to see what this forum could come up with. Some links that may be helpful: Wikipedia Page Wiki Steam Page Subreddit Since I found this game I've been desperate for someone to share it with and I decided this forum was probably the best place. I also wanted to show off my own network as I am very happy with how it's coming along. I hope I've helped someone find a game they'll enjoy. All the best, LNERW1

No, as the article says it was only proposed but was rejected for being unfeasible for a multitude of reasons. I think it's fascinating though as it would have substantially changed that area of Laois.

Found this while researching for a CBA on the Kilkenny-Portlaoise railway line. A search for "Mountmellick railway station" yielded this. Interesting idea, but in fairness it would likely have closed well outside of living memory, and Lord knows looking for information on it would be like hen's teeth. Interesting read nevertheless and well worth a look.

By my guesswork there’s 18 grand worth of models on those shelves. You could buy three working, reliable cars for that. Maybe four a-tiny-bit-shite ones at a push. Ah, I see. Money is not the issue for you, you are clearly a man of impeccable taste. I’m sorry for ever doubting you. (That’s a mad amount of sausages, you’ll have a heart attack if you eat all them within less than a year-but in fairness I’d say we’re all as bad anyway)

That is a very good way to show off insane wealth. Do you have any OO wagons?

Should have seen that coming... nevermind then. Sorry about that.

EDIT: as clarified by Darius below, all Rue d'Etropal products were available on the now-defunct Shapeways Marketplace, and they do not seem to have been made available anywhere else yet, meaning they are not accessible at the moment. Rue D’Etropal (3d printed models) do Clayton rail cars, also suitable for your setting. There’s also a couple MGWR coaches that, I have to say, have me tempted. http://www.rue-d-etropal.com/3D-printing/3d_printed_Irish-5ft-3in-gauge-trains1.htm Hope this is of help.

I’ve had the same thing happen-13,162! I know everyone loves me (wink wink) but I think it could be bots trying to collect data as I seem to be one of the few members who’s filled in all the “about me” boxes. That’s the best hypothesis I have at the moment.

Tipp-ex could probably be used as some sort of white paint in a pinch. There are three main forms in which you can purchase the stuff, and I can think of at least one use for each. Pot and sponge/brush: general white paint- you would have to be in quite a pinch in fairness but it isn’t too off-white so it could be passable. ”Shake ‘n’ Squeeze” applicator pen: lining. It is difficult to use precisely but it’s easy enough to learn how to make smaller marks with it. If you had some masking tape on hand it would make neatness a lot easier. You likely wouldn’t need any fancy stuff either as Tipp-ex is fairly viscous and so would probably have trouble getting under tape. Those little tape-mouse thingies: Lining on platform edges. To be honest that’s the best I can think of. If you found a wagon with the right size planks it could conceivably be used to recolour some planks on a wooden wagon to give the effect of replacement, but that would probably only be useful in larger scales, and let’s face it, if you’re modelling in a scale large enough for this to be viable, money is likely not a problem for you. Or at least it wouldn’t be if you didn’t spend it all on trains. Now please keep in mind I haven’t tried any of this. I just felt an urgent need to post something and feel somewhat useful, so these are just some thoughts that I’ve had floating around for a while. All the best, LNERW1.

I happen to know Ronnie- he gifted me this: As well as many books on railways across the world. I may talk to him for the project. A true gentleman indeed.

Just looking for sources on the Portlaoise-Kilkenny line for a CBA I’m doing in school at the moment. Wikipedia doesn’t have much info, and so doesn’t seem to have any very useful sources beyond a YouTube video on Attanagh station. I may also turn the project into a YouTube video as I believe it has potential to do well, but at the moment just focusing on the school side of it. So, if anyone has sources, be they online, physical or anecdotal, please do share them. Any history or enthusiast website is fine, but forums would have to be listed as anecdotal. This isn’t a massive problem of course as it’s not a Junior or Leaving Cert CBA. Also if supplying photos of book pages, please provide the title, authors, ISBN and page number, if any of this is not already visible. Thanks for your time and i hope with all my picky demands some useful information can squeeze in. All the best, LNERW1.

How have you found the Leader, out of curiosity? KR seem to be catching a lot of flack for it. Quite an unpopular locomotive and company, it seems. Do you have an opinion either way? Edit: NEVER MIND. read the preceding post. That will teach me a lesson. Hopefully. Sorry

I would say, as someone less experienced than the rest of the people here, the best thing to do is look at what you want and see how you can achieve that with the space, materials, skills and time you have. I’m very much still finding my way in the hobby so am probably not the best source of advice around, but I am very sure of this. I’ve made the mistake before of claiming or trying to do things that I simply cannot and so have disappointed myself and maybe one or two others several times. I would say from the experience I do have that its best to keep your aspirations realistic and work with and around what you have. I don’t know how talented or experienced you are so I can’t give any more specific help but I really do hope I’ve been of help here, if nowhere else on this site.

JHB: frantically checks model room for bugging devices

Two new additions wait at Mantelpiece Halt. Thanks to @Killian Keane for the Peckett and @WRENNEIRE for the G class, great deals on both and lovely models. They both manage to run quite nicely on the frankly quite dirty track of my and my brother’s tailchaser so I don’t doubt they’ll run even more smoothly on better maintained track.

I misread the initial post- thought it was next Friday- ah well, there’s always next time. Realised after tye webinar was over and watched Blues Brothers to cheer myself up. As I said, there’s always next time but Loughrea would have been a great reference for my layout. Sorry I ended up missing it after you were so helpful, Leslie.

That’s brilliant! How much is the signal cabin?

Great. I am (well my mam is on my behalf, being under 18 is a bit of a pain sometimes) an IRRS member but that’s great, thanks for the fast reply Leslie.

Way Out West- Workshop Stuff on YouTube for anyone interested. Absolutely brilliant channel, Tim Rowe is a great engineer. Any time I see a new video I have to click. One of the best channels on YouTube and I couldn’t praise it enough. Also, the railway is visible on OpenStreetMap for anyone interested in the precise layout. Just east of Ballylickey. All great fun and very inventive, have to say I wish nothing but success for them.

In fairness the photo is absolutely shocking… (I’m far too deep into this forum now to not be making awful puns. To be honest I’m surprised no one else got there first!) Is the webinar for all IRRS members?

Absolutely devastated you model in N. I’d snap these up in a heartbeat in 4mm. I’m sure they’ll be gone by noon anyway. I’d pay a lot of money (if I had it) for models like these for my own layout. Hope you make top dollar for them, you deserve it.

Ah I see. I have to say that’s quite a good solution to the problem but I don’t doubt it was somewhat of a pain to construct. Anyway that question aside I love the (almost all of) rest of the layout, keep up the good work but I notice the roads still haven’t been done! Tsk, tsk. (if not obvious I am of course joking. If you prefer them like that who am I to stop you. Or if you just haven’t got around to it yet I’m the last person to reprimand you!)

@Metrovik top photo may be a good reference for you.

I thought to further push my point about T gauge modelling as a serious concept, I should post some comparisons. Most Irish stock can be replicated in T with reasonable accuracy considering the scale, using only products from Tgauge.com I list below the products needed as the bare bones of Irish models. Below is the Intercity and/or locomotive fleet, as listed on Wikipedia. 22000 class: 23 metre coaches, SKU 029 + 23 metre motorised chassis, SKU 049-B 201 Class: 6 axle 21 Metre motorised chassis, SKU 015-6ax Mark 4: 16-27m adjustable chassis (black), SKU 023-B* 071 Class: Closest match is the 6 Axle 18.5 Metre Motorised Chassis, SKU 016-6ax, this is nearly a scale metre over-length, but as it is such a small scale this difference should be indetectable. I'm using Wikipedia as a source for train and locomotive lengths, but it doesn't list the lengths of any Commuter units. *Another problem caused by Wikipedia. It lists the Mark 4's as either 7 or 8 car trains but only gives one train length, not specifying which it is. This length is 189.43 metres. I worked out that if this referred to a 7-car unit it would make it about 21m long, but referring to an 8-car train it would make each car around 20m. I then googled it and realised it worked out at between 27 metres if 7-car and 23 if 8-car. I decided to play it safe and list an adjustable chassis, but I could be wrong. if they are around 190 metres at 8 cars that means you could use the same chassis as the 22000s. Also some former Irish Rail and CIÉ locos here: A class: 6 Axle 16 Metre Motorised Chassis, SKU 027-06ax C, 121, 141 and 181 class locos are all similarly disadvantaged here in that they are too short to be accurately represented by a Tgauge.com chassis. Using a shorter dummy chassis with a powered wagon or coach behind would probably work well here. B101 Class: Could be passably represented by a 6 Axle 16 Metre Motorised Chassis, SKU 027-06ax, but this is around a scale 1.5m too long. Not as noticable as the up to 4m difference between the scale length of this chassis and the real-life lenght of the above locos, but still possibly too noticable. 301 Class: Could be passably represented at this scale by the BR Class 08 Shunter, SKU 008. This loco's chassis could also be useful for producing other 0-6-0s -the J15 springs to mind- and possibly even a motorised wagon or brakevan for some of the shorter locos listed above. Finally, freight and departmental. I don't have great knowledge of IÉ (and IR, in fairness) freight stock so this will be short and sweet, but generally Tgauge.com's generic freight stock should do a good enough job of representing Irish freight stock. Unfortunately Tgauge.com does not offer any 4-wheel wagon or wagon chassis. This would be pretty pointless as such a small model would likely be difficult to manufacture and fiddly to use, not to mention fragile. The site does offer 4- wheel bogies, though, and I have no doubt they could be turned into passable 4 wheel wagons. The Track Maintenance Vehicle, SKU 09-TG, is a passable representation of IÉ's ballast tamper (I think there's only one). Finally, anyone wanting to make or modify their own T gauge models should head to the "Spares" page, https://www.tgauge.com/section/7/1/spares. This offers loads of detail and mechanical parts. One last thing, if anyone has carriage measurements for any Commuter or DART trains, please share them. Wikipedia doesn't list these and so I'm not sure what chassis would work best to represent them. Thanks, LNERW1.

Always great to have accurate diecast vehicles for Irish modellers. Looks beautifully detailed as well.