Jump to content

Noel

Members
  • Posts

    7,487
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    150

Everything posted by Noel

  1. One word - Comfort (on inter city trips) In fairness compared to other older ICRs the 22k sets are an improvement, but nowhere near as comfortable on a long trip as the mk3 and mk4 coaching sets. Aside from noise and vibration, the main difference is the hard SEATS which are very uncomfortable on a long trip. Fine for a commute but not for long rail journeys. As for the 2600, 2700, 2800 and 29000 (really 2900) they remind me of my time working behind the "iron curtain" many years ago. I understand the economics of ICRs, but UK, France and Germany can operate fixed rake intercity loco sets that don't need shunting nor run arounds at termini using mainly twin power cars at each end of the rake, or push pull. Same cost savings on labour, simpler track work at termini, fast turnaround. The 22k sets are just not comfortable enough for "Inter city" routes. The motorway is more comfortable. Nothing to do with emotional nostalgia for locos, just quiet coaches that are comfortable to sit in for 2 to 4 hours. On trips to Cork and Kerry we only go Irish Rail if we can book on a mk4 set. Never again will I do a 3 hour rail journey on those 22000 seats.
  2. Mk4 set viewed from another Mk4 set. 232 set passing 215 set. The comfort of the Mk4 sets is so superior to the noisy, vibrating hard seated 22k sets.
  3. Cannot wait to see this emerge.
  4. Claremorris has to be the most interesting station in Ireland. The rail metropolis of its hey day. Fives lines in and out of it!
  5. Have to agree. I never liked LJ. It just didn't seem to operate like a proper station. It always looked like half of it was missing. A main station in the middle of nowhere. Now Claremorris is a different kettle of fish, it is an awesome station and junction extrodinaire.
  6. He has. CM has so much more operating potential and diverse traffic than LJ. LJ also very award to model in 00 due to length required, not to mention the most boring looking station lacking a platform on the other side of the main line. It's like a sentence without a full stop, or a goods train without a brake van - unfinished! But I suspect CM will be worth waiting for.
  7. PS: IT, where did you source the sprung buffers?
  8. Super posts IT, on your A class project. Don't know how I missed this thread. Excellent. The video proves how well she runs with your adapted chassis. Great bit of model engineering.
  9. Two MM baby GMs went for sensible money earlier this evening. Sold from Ireland. MM0141 http://www.ebay.ie/itm/321946279386?_trksid=p2055119.m1438.l2649&ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT €83 MM0181 http://www.ebay.ie/itm/321946290979?_trksid=p2055119.m1438.l2649&ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT €108
  10. Darwin
  11. Noel

    Sulzer Kit

    Very nice
  12. Noel

    Sulzer Kit

    I can think of two suggestions
  13. Noel

    Sulzer Kit

    Hat's off! Apologies I meant the many of us who suffer 16.5mm instead of the few revered Irish modellers who use 21mm layouts.
  14. Noel

    Sulzer Kit

    Yes exactly! They excelled in both (i.e. scale appearance + scale running). I think we got crossed wires. I was referring to some very fine looking kit built models that however run on chassis that do not do them justice (i.e. don't run in a scale like manner).
  15. Noel

    Sulzer Kit

    Mind you getting quite pernickity about exactness rather than overall impression feels strange given our 16.5mm track gauge seems as far off scale as perhaps a missing wheel. When looking at a model train in operation, realistic scale movements seem equally as important as a good looking fine scale model. No use looking 100% perfectly authentic if it moves like a toy, accelerates like a Ferrari and brakes at a scale 4g throwing imaginary passengers against carriage bulk heads when stopping at a station. A good balance between a great looking model that runs well will look the real thing. Can't have one without the other unless its for a display case.
  16. Noel

    Sulzer Kit

    Hmmm! Well I'm considering putting a Bachmann class 25 bo-bo chassis under an A class body. Its a perfect fit without lengthening or shortening. It'll be a cheat but at least it will run well unlike the Hornby plod, and pass the 2ft rule and closer in stations as the platforms hide the under frames and bogies anyway.
  17. L Oh Yummie. I nearly fell off my perch when I saw that photo. B&T heaven.
  18. Yes fab pic, and it was a classic livery, however that dull livery never blow my skirt up! It wasn't until the tippex livery emerged that I realised just how dull the supertrain livery looked. Scale does strange things to colour, while the ST livery was more familiar to my memory, I prefer the IR tippex livery on models. It just seems to scale better visually. I'm tempted to respray one of my 071s Black'n'Tan just for fun despite the fact they never had it. I have a silver and black one and I just don't like the look of it.
  19. I hope you don't drive your car everywhere in reverse JB, and that your number plates are not upside down!
  20. Ah that must have been major Dawnay & co heading to the park for a few chukkas
  21. Thanks. Mixing up liveries and running an Enterprise/NI liveried loco with an Irish Rail coach set seems untidy and a bit of a mess. Is the enterprise fleet not self contained?
  22. Thanks for the update. Ordered a rake, look forward to receiving it some time next year.
  23. Interesting but it looks a bit of a mess. Wonder how reliabley it worked with those interlaced crossings and points. Must have been a bit of a maintenance nightmare, but I guess the stock only moved at walking pace so not as many derailments as one might expect, or easy to fix if any occurred.
  24. Agree - Whoever owns it, the "Hornby" brand most likely probably never die. I hope they turn the business around. From Hornby-Dublo, Triang, Triang-Hornby to Hornby its an iconic brand that has introduced generations in this part of the world to model trains.
  25. You know what they say: "Revenue is Vanity, Profit is Sanity"
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use